Tuesday, February 17, 2009

The Liquidity Trap, I’m a Believer

Paul Krugman, the influential Sith Lord columnist has finally convinced me that America is indeed in a Liquidity Trap. However, I have to add a few tweaks and variables to his thinking.

The traditional “Liquidity Trap” is as follows: Financial meltdown scares the public into saving money and not spending. Aggregate demand then falls, lowering prices. Companies begin to shed workers because of this fall in demand. More unemployed people spend less and discourage other consumers even more. Aggregate demand then falls, lowering prices. The cycle repeats.

Here is my “Liquidity Trap” as follows: Financial meltdown scares the public into saving money and not spending. The government does something reckless and foolish like a bank bailout, hurting future expectations of economic growth and recovery, which kills stock prices. Aggregate demand then falls, lowering prices. Aggregate demand begins to recover, and then the government does something reckless and foolish like a stimulus. Stocks fall, demand drops, inflation retreats. Recovery begins and then the government does something reckless and foolish like announcing a vague new bailout plan. Stocks fall, demand drops, inflation retreats.

Here’s the cycle more clearly in 6 easy steps:

1. Bank panic
2. Stocks crash
3. Government Panics and Screws Things Up
4. Stocks tank again, treasuries surge, inflation falls
5. Stocks begin to recover, treasuries decline, inflation starts to pick up
6. Return to step 3.

I had believed massive inflation was inevitable because the Federal Reserve is cranking out the dough like Pillsbury, but apparently, all the government has to do is slowly but surely destroy the economy to head this off. It's amazing how closely the data fits my new model. Hopefully Obama’s cabinet doesn’t run out of bad ideas anytime soon, or we’re all screwed.

2 comments:

dave said...

Brian,
You need to add a step 7 thru 10.

7. stocks crash again (like yesterday)

8. investors sell treasuries and buy gold ( like yesterday)

9. Dollar goes to hell and so does inflation (coming soon )

Brian Shelley said...

Dave,

That's the thing. Everything that I understand points me to steps 8 and 9. There's a general trend out of treasuries and into gold. Day after day, this is the trend. Then the government passes some dumb bill or makes some dumb announcement and everyone rushes back into treasuries and inflation indicators fall as well. It seems that these policy induced panics are keeping the economy from reaching its inevitable end.